Final Fantasy VII
Yes, I finally beat the game from 26 years ago! I'd tried it a couple of times before throughout my life, and never even made it out of Midgar, but wanting to finish it before FF7 Rebirth comes out motivated me to stick with it, and I'm glad it did. It's obviously got some old game jankiness, and some very much "guide dangit" moments, even ignoring secret bosses and weapons and stuff, but overall I'm surprised how well it held up, and how hard the story hits. I would definitely recommend giving it a shot to anyone who's interested.
Grade: B+ (I know this is probably unfairly low, but I never got into a JRPG until Persona 4 Golden, so I don't really have a way to judge how good it was "for the time," so this is just my current enjoyment of it)