TheRevanchist

ME2 had the better gameplay. Everything else I felt ME1 did better. And unfortunately on a Star Wars RPG, gameplay isn't my primary concern

I actually think that in terms of both gameplay and mechanics ME3 is the best (I just wish they'd allowed squad armor customization along the lines of what they did with weapons), but in terms of plot/storyline/pacing/general atmosphere ME1 is still the best. Like WaS says though, it's all that other stuff I'm looking for in a Star Wars RPG.

I wouldn't be able to tell you my disappointment if they decided to make it as linear as a grand part of ME2. The thing I loved of the old KOTOR titles is all the planets you could revisit and the side missions in each. ME3 boiled down to 'get me this part from sending a probe to planet X'