Perhaps this might be a tad late but I've been lurking Kotaku for about four years. I never registered because I found (and still do) the star commenting system to be asinine and counterproductive...especially when star commenters would bully nonstarred commenters, or my favorite when they would promote trolls only to strike them down, dismissing them with a token comment: "Ignorant troll. Don't feed the troll," etc. But my least favorite person was Joel. He sucked. Lately Owen has replaced him. I'm in the minority that likes Bashcraft--his randomness spices up Kotaku. Anyhow I miss old commenters who had insightful things to say like MasterDex, or deanb (yes the admin), Komrade Kayce, DukeofPwn, etc. A lot of them have left. But they were the people that made Kotaku the site I had to frantically check 6-8 times a day. Now it's not the same. But I have found this site with promises of greatness.