Rocksmith! I got the guitar bundle, but the guitar was badly defective - it slipped out of tune every 3 minutes or so, and man it hurt my fingers using the frets, but that's normal for newbies, right? All the fret exercises were trial and error since it never accepted the one I was holding down. So I read up on it and did some troubleshooting - tune the intonation! ...can't really do that on this guitar... not per string anyway. Adjust the action - the strings should be about 5/64" over the 12th fret... mine are... 31/64"! Oh hey, what's this... the neck is leaning forward from the body and the screw holes that should hold it on are all slack! That's no good...
So after letting my numb index finger heal for a couple days, I went and returned it, kept the software and got an Epiphone SG Special. Much better! Nice tone. More features. Significantly lighter too. It set me back about $210 (CAD), where the Rocksmith bundle was $200 - $80 for the software, leaving about $120 of that for the Epiphone Les Paul Jr that it came with. Still, it was the cheapest electric with humbucker pickups I could find, and really about as little as you could spend on an electric guitar with a straight face it seems. Reviews I've found roundly praise it as an entry-level unit and I'm certainly not advanced enough to take issue with it! The only advice I'd add for someone taking the same route is to get a leather, not nylon strap, since whenever I reach for my PS3 controller to navigate menus and skip prompts, my guitar twists down and the nylon strap rubs on my neck because it's so low friction.
The game? Great so far! It doesn't allow a lot of room for fiddling with the basics (though you can specifically tell it to give you basic drills again and again, it prefers to run you through a bunch of simple versions of songs and ratchet up the difficulty as soon as you get the hang of it.) The difficulty creep is a good confidence builder at times and would be good to keep perfectionists from getting complacent with easy drills. My only problem so far is that I've received some really crappy scores for not doing things that it hasn't explained anywhere yet. I just played a song with 96% accuracy and got about 6000 points out of 100,000, probably because I didn't line-with-an-X-though-it enough. No promises, but when I get more proficient I might even try penning a more in depth review for the site.
For some background, I figured investing in this wouldn't be a bad idea since I love rhythm games. I got into Pop'n Music 3 around 1999 and soon after, the early Beatmania (or technically, "beatmania") games, which I kinda hated until I found Beatmania: Best Hits. I played those pretty regularly up through about Beatmania IIDX: 14th style. I love Pentavision's DJ Max PSP games and have all 5 Korean releases (I once pulled off a 15,000 note combo across several songs...) I haven't totally beat, but have made it far in Gitaroo Man, and Hatsune Miku: Project Diva. Most other games like Space Channel 5 1&2, Bust A Move 1&2, Parappa the Rapper, Puyo Puyo DA! etc are all fun, but pretty easy with that background. More recently, I beat the great multi-DDR dungeon indie game "Sequence" in about a week on normal mode. So in other words, I'm a music game nut and not too likely to drop Rocksmith unless I master it - and if I do? Mission accomplished! (For now though, I'm quite the guitar noob... but still surprised how quickly I've progressed just trying what Rocksmith throws at me!)