I'm partial to the Academy of Interactive Arts and Science Awards myself.
As for the VGAs, I thought they were pretty good for a mainstream production. Still a few things to nit pick over, but overall, a solid production imo. My biggest gripe wasn't even with the show itself, but the shortlist of games to vote on. It focused more on, "What are the best selling games this year with the highest metacritic score" as opposed to titles that felt truly deserving. At least, that's my $0.02.