Finally beat Catherine late last night. Man, it's good to have this one scratched off the backlog. I hated having it there. Loved the game but ended up losing interest because of a damn difficulty spike when I first bought it over a year ago.
The story is about as good as you would expect from the Persona team. Only issue there is your choices don't always mesh with how Vincent acts in cutscenes. As far as I'm aware, only the ending is affected by those. As for the gameplay, as someone who loves both difficult games and puzzle games, this game fits in a weird niche that's kinda perfect for me. The only problem is that the difficulty curve is kind of all over the place. It starts out easy enough and slowly ramps up as the game introduces new concepts. But suddenly around halfway through it just spikes out of nowhere and one boss level in particular feels like they programmed a variable called "bullshit" and just cranked it WAY up. There is so much shit coming at you from every single direction that you almost need luck to not walk into something that kills you by complete accident. This is around the part where I'd initially stopped.
Here's where it gets weird, though. After that boss, it kinda gets easier. I mean, I guess it's possible I just got significantly better at the game without realizing it. But I really doubt it. I feel like the game is at its best when it throws difficult puzzles at you but doesn't rush you through them (i.e. doesn't actively try to fucking murder you so you actually have time to think). And the last few levels are a lot like that, even the bosses aren't trying as hard to climb right up your ass. Not the final boss, though. Holy shit, fuck that asshole. It's like they didn't know what to do so they just went back to that bullshit variable from earlier and fucking broke it on purpose. Here, there were times I literally died because I stepped on the wrong block at the wrong time, without any real way to know what was coming. It was infuriating. I don't think there even exists words of profanity hateful enough to do justice to my hatred for that motherfucker.
But yeah, other than those two difficulty walls, I absolutely loved the game. I kinda want to keep playing it. I mean, there's trophies I could hunt or go for some of the other endings. But really, it's just more of the gameplay that I want. That hasn't happened in a while. I think XCOM was the last time.