Yantelope

To me retro starts at the 16-bit generation but I'm willing to extend it to the PSX-N64 generation these days.

Haha, I just copied over the list from the old country so I didn't pick the ones that were already on there.

10. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 9. Halo 3 8. Super Mario Galaxy 7. Gears of War 6. Fallout 2 5. StarCraft II 4. Uncharted 2 3. Red Dead Redemption 2. GoldenEye (N64) 1. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas

we need a Boourns emoticon.

boourns.

That's what this thread usually boils down into. I intiailly interpreted it to mean critically overrated. GTA:SA was a great example of a game with stellar reviews even though it was just a rehash of a rehash of a game. Really though, in this thread it's up to you to decide why something is overrated. It would be nice to give some reasoning to back it up. I think Uncharted 2 is critically overrated because it's just an average shooter with some overly long climbing sections and I thought both Batman AA and Assassin's Creed 2 were more deserving of GOTY last year.

sorry, Pheer isn't the only one with nothing to do at work. Her head is surprisingly iconic, isn't it? So it would seem

I was laughing to myself because I thought it was Jada Pinkett Smith's head but then I realized it really was Jada Pinkett Smith's head.

Enter the Matrix

world of goo

quit your whining and up your game son.

prince of persia

suck it trebeck!

kareoke revolution

singstar

/me frantically presses F5

Wario Ware?

laser clay shooting system?

yeah, but that reticule isn't in duck hunt.

You can only edit for 30 minutes after you post.

ITT: Pheer hits F5 repeatedly.

Time for some redistribution of wealth. The man is trying to keep us down!

Yeah, that one was too easy.