So played and completed Uncharted 3 yesterday/this morning.
First off: Fuck online pass things. (soot for Uncharted 2 being Online Pass free)
So as stated in the "games you've beat" I prefer Uncharted 2. I feel UC3 was much of a muchness, still a very good and generally well crafted muchness, but the whole chasing convoys, escaping crashing vehicles, collapsing cities stuff has been done already. I disliked two parts about Uncharted 3.
1.
15 years later and Naughty Dog bring back one of the worst parts of Crash Bandicoot. The "running towards the camera" levels. Yes your water is all splashy and fancy and you want to show it off, surely there's other ways? It's just terrible to play cos unless you have absolutely awesome level design it becomes very much a case of trial and error until the player learnt all the path.
2. One of the puzzles really really sucked. First time in a while I've had to check out a walkthrough. I still don't get it. Line up the random limbs, understood that, put the cogs in the right way, the journal tells you that one easy enough. But this one (Which apart from having a thumb obscure part of the journal for) just made no sense at all, especially when the symbols changed depending on the angle.
(and a minor one would be they changed the models of Chloe and Elina. They're slightly more oriental and photoshopped magazine cover-like.)
As for the rest it's all solid Unchartedness. Shooting, puzzles, platforming, set pieces, drake dying when falling 10 feet etc etc. The fighting is improved, though I've just come to this after finishing Arkham City which unfortunately most games will pale to in that respect. I appreciate that they also removed the super hard end bossfight that Uncharted 2 had (which btw Charlie, the English geezer, is the same VA as Lozarvic in UC2), and it all kinda added a nice bit of backstory (rather enjoyed the early young drake bit) and fleshed out the characters some more. Though they kept in the god damn "semi-mythical creatures as bad guys near the end of the game" bit. Fucking loved it when I came across a normal merc and he went down in a few bullets.
edit: Dislike 3: I felt many of the fights only seemed to increase in difficulty because they just added more people into the fights. It didn't feel very tactical, and stealth was pointless for all but the first one or two kills.
edit2:
I liked that they made use of this illusion a fair few times.