I'll probably regret this later, but what the hell.
Anyway thought I'd bring it up cos I read some interesting quotes on Gamasutra today I thought kind of vaguely summed up my thoughts on the matter:
http://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/32840/Zyngas_Tian_Games_Are_Craft_Not_Art.php
Yes it's Zynga, but it'd be stupid to completely dismiss it because of that.
I've always been of the thought they're not exactly an art. Yes there may be many artistic elements, but it's mostly added on and unnecessary; it may have writing work for it, but it doesn't need it to be a game. It may have fancy graphics or FMVs, doesn't need it either. A novel without writing is nothing, a movie without moving images, is just a Voice over. etc.
What games have in common, from Pong to Uncharted to Ico is programming. And you'd be hard pushed to call that art. But it is a craft, it's a skill. Even the more flamboyant looking games than Pong level stuff it's closer to design than art. Which the two are separate. Design has aesthetic, but planned and functional form. That's why it's Web design, Architectural design, Product design etc. I think many folks who argue that games are art get art and design mixed up. My Bed is not intended to be slept in. It's purely for the aesthetic. Whereas games are functional, they have to, to be playable. MS Office is also functional and programmed (and up until 2003 version had games built in too)
Also I'm not putting games down. Nothing will change in gaming anyway whether they were called art or not. I kind of find the whole thing to be a bit of a farce. Call of Duty isn't suddenly going to get better plotlines because some unknown organization headed by, I assume from the way folks go on about him in this matter, Roger Ebert declares games art. Shadow of the Colossus won't get any less moving because it's called programming.
It just seems like gamers grasping for straws in some effort to say their past time is more worthwhile than person x's past time.
Oh n anyone who suggests that art is something that evokes an emotional response? I will ban you. And if you get pissed off at that I shall submit your ban report to be hung up at the Tate gallery.