2 Was still scary for me, but I'm jumpy like a pogo stick* so... The atmosphere was pretty creepy too, so that's why both are about the same for me. I played parts of 3 with a friend, but never the whole game, though I did look up the stuff that happens to the other player, and that was pretty fucking cool, but the fact that it required two people to get the most out of it means that I didn't get to enjoy it as much. Also, some weapons were hilariously overpowered, which made the game really fun, but kinda took away from the creepy/horror aspects that made the others awesome. I like 3, I think it's a really fun game that did some cool stuff with its coop mode, just that it lacked some of the stuff that made the other two my favourite horror games.
The DLC was pretty cool too, and the ending was fucking awesome. \m/ \m/
*I jumped out of my chair while playing Wildlands.