I still think they put out some good stuff on each album, but they're definitely not going to match Clarity again.
Apparently, they 'got away' with that album at the time due to a lot less studio-tinkering.
That's what I thought too, but I'm pretty sure they recorded Bleed American pretty much by themselves, which was their mainstream breakout hit (although I still love most of it).
I was disappointed in Futures, liked the EP they put out, liked what I heard of their album after that, but I listened to a web stream of their latest and I was super disappointed - so many of the songs were just cheesy and blah.
On topic of Jimmy Eat World, has anyone heard Lapko?
They're a Finnish band that kind of sounds like a slightly heavier Jimmy Eat World.