I'm with P4, that's not really something to slam anyone for. You may have had multiple twitter accounts beffy, but not at the same time:
Rockpapershotgun had same issue yesterday https://twitter.com/...641589131489280
And it's really easy for us lot to do it too:
http://dl.dropbox.co...witter_PXOD.PNG
I don't get the cornfield because it's the most blatant and public signs of how they moderate the comments. You're fine to discuss the topic in the article, but don't discuss the article itself, don't disagree with the opinion of the article, don't point out factual errors. They're very thin skinned which doesn't help. Then on with a heaping of snark in responses. I'm going to say in my year or so away from kotaku and dipping my toes in other online communities and such, especially reddit in the past few months, it's obvious that kotaku is not liked at all. And I think it has been that way for a while, so while they can't control what external forces have to say about their site, they can tidy it up when it is on kotaku.
Heck how many other gaming sites get called out by others as in the case of PCG with this "pro gaming" stuff. (And I'm sure it's not the only time another site has called out Kotaku, probably a few other examples in this thread)
Joel was/is a Gizmodo writer so he's aware of gawker policy on dealing with commenters. Though his response to Tiller was pretty surprising compared to the normal reaction. And it would be egotistical, but I do agree with your assessment. Even being banned from the site for a year I still get recognised around and about the web. And I did provide a fair few tips and such for them. This is the funny thing, I used to be quite a fan. The steam group, a forum, a guide for the site etc. Yet here I am 2 years later posting in the "Fucking Kotaku" thread. They do say you make your own enemies. And I don't think anyone has ever mastered Crecente in that art. Dude really needs some lessons in something. I dunno, could start with "being nice" before moving on to more advanced topics of "Snark isn't smart".
I posted in Talk Amongst Yourselves. http://kotaku.com/55...847675#comments . Which is funny cos later on in my banning when being quizzed on it Crecente said about not posting stuff like that in regular articles but to post in : Speakup, Kotaku off-topic or...Talk Amongst Yourselves.(though at the time Speakup didn't exist). Or to email them, but you guys are aware by now how that goes. At least Crecente the usual "don't tell us what to do, stop reading the site" stuff. Though Bash is pretty good with emails. Most of my emails to him in the past were just "that story is a dupe" or minor corrections and his response were pretty good. I may disagree with his choice of content to post about but he's at least got good netiquette.
Thursday I think my tl;dr might be better (if not funnier): http://dl.dropbox.co...nbmmvdotwar.JPG
Basically Kotaku has a huge issue with community. They want one cos it helps provide hits. But they don't want to, nor know how to, deal with it. We're not in 1984, the hivemind will not always agree. And how you deal with it is what is important. If you cornfield, delete, ban any disagreement no matter how well put then it's just not going to end up well. If they were to just take Crecente aside for a bit, heck maybe Put Totilo in his position instead, then it might help matters a fair amount.
edit: I maybe should email Joel tonight. No idea why or what for mind. As I've said already it's far too little far too late. Most of it's active members have moved on given the pretty shit reaction for Kotaku writers to the group over the years it's not really surprising. All it has spent the past year doing is dwindling in members. About only reason we still have a bunch is because people can't be arsed to leave groups though a fair amount are: http://dl.dropbox.com/u/2066351/Screenshots/Kotaku/netloss.PNG That small burst the other day is when Tiller posted about it. Pretty mcuh the past few months has been a constat "person x left group". Also http://steamcommunity.com/groups/kotakuites/announcements/detail/1027014441691256545 now note the current amount we have. We actually got close to 3,400 at one point.
So yeah I don't know much what's to discuss. The people who used to buy and run servers for it, post up events etc have pretty much moved on. Apart from the standard E3 there hasn't been an event for ages. The group is for all intents and purposes dead.