Ghost in the Shell
Visually it's great. Upon Blu-Ray release I'll be poring all over its design. Some of the cinematography was pretty dang cool too (There's a raid midway through that's done from a birds eye view which is pretty cool looks a bit like an old RTS...or I guess Satellite Reign).Batou was absolutely a stand out for me (to be fair I quite enjoy him in SAC too). And there was complaints on his eyes being black instead of white, but they're clearly shown as lenses in this and lenses are black (I'm to understand it was prosthetic too which is cool, and I can believe that given they have done quite a bit of practical stuff). In fact the practical stuff is pretty great considering it's the kind of film you could easily do it all green screen with balls on sticks and such. Obviously the hologram stuff is all CGI mind.
They also use this kind of cool cross between motion blur and slow mo that kinda looks like a toned down localised version of the "slowmo" effect in Dredd). It's really cool in a scene where Major is being attacked by three guys with glowing taser batons and they're leaving like a stream of light behind them. And also seen when she's fighting to show she's moving at super human speeds and motions (which despite a bit I'm about to complain on is well shown when she kicks a guy in the chest about 30 feet).
I put it in the okay section as;
I felt the ending was quite anti-climatic. It fell a bit flat and I felt that the film kinda seemed short. I've seen someone suggest it could have done with like a bog standard mission with the team near the start, bit more establishing of Section 9 and the team and I do agree with that assessment.
The invisible fight in the shallow water was waayyy too fan servicey in having little reason to be in this film other than it was a cool bit of the original film. There are quite a few things from the original film and I'd say many of the fit in being reproduced (I got my wish for a scene with the fingers), but this felt a bit too forced and contrived.
Aramaki was cool, and in fact I'd say cooler than he is in the originals. And was a really nice element that he spoke in subbed Japanese (I watch stuff dubbed so they all speak English...except when they speak Latin :P). Nice touch to show that cos of the cyber brains you just have things auto-translated for you.
Which brings us to Scarlets character.
She plays a character called "Major Mira Killian", which as we all know is a super Japanese name and there has been issues on her playing a totally Japanese character.
So in summary:
Looks great, characters are great, some weird editing/directing choices that make it a bit flat. I'm totally up for watching it again and digesting it some more. (compared to AC which I'm less inclined to)