Thinking about it now, I dont remember shit about GTAV. Not in the way I still remember RDR.
I finished the main storyline, which I wasnt impressed with and I never went back to it. Im not sure if its maybe a a handful of people who have totally gotten over sandbox games or if there might be some kind of big backlash coming soon. Im impressed by the work that went into the city in GTAV(hands down the most "alive" city in any game Ive played), but Im completley neutral to the thing. It could have been twice as big or a fourth of what it was and it wouldnt have mattered to me.
QTEs and sandbox games as we know them now grew up together and people hate QTEs now because they added nothing to the actual game and proved to be very boring. I feel the same way about sandbox games. Watchdogs really puts into perspective how samey these things can be. "Just another fucking sandbox game."
I like big open cities as a way to feel immersed in a living world, but I hate that developers have to come up with dumb shit for players to do in it. I doubt they really want to do it. They do it because its expected, not because they were overflowing with gameplay ideas and the only way to express them was by creating a huge ass city. And you can tell.
Thats why Ive always been a huge fan of the inFamous series. It always takes place in a big city, but its not a sandbox, it's open world. You can run, fly or grind rails around beating the shit out of enemies, which is the main and often only type of gameplay. Just traversal and combat. Those games were always so refined and smooth compared to any other series with big cities in them. To a lesser extent, Assassin's Creed does the same thing. The cities are a singular tool to create immersion, nothing more. Its a stage.
I hated GTA4 and really liked GTA5 for being so different from it, but I think the only things different was that GTA5 had fun driving and the game had an old school GTA sense of humor. I think thats what really saved it for me. Otherwise theyre about the same.
I wonder how the remaster will review or if itll make anyone second guess all those high scores it got the first time.
RDR is Rockstar's best game and it just might be because compared to the GTA series, there's very little to do outside of hunting and poker.