I can't find my original so I made a new one.
So I went at this with the mindset of what games I played the most or impacted me the most, not necessarily my favorite games.
1. Quest for Glory 1: So this game had character classes, individual skill trees, puzzles with multiple solutions depending upon your class, multiple endings and your skills ranked depending on your actions. Oh, and this game came out back in 1989.
2. Street Fighter 2: If you weren't around back when this game hit arcades you don't realize what an impact this game truly had but pretty much every quarter you had as a child went into this thing so much so that my brother and I considered spending $83 on the SNES cart a deal because of all the quarters we were going to save ourselves.
3. Final Fantasy VI (III): This game opened my eyes to what storytelling in a videogame could be. It also had me hooked on JRPGs for the next decade.
4. Final Fantasy VII: The game that created emo. I wont rehash all the arguments for this one. I will say that my mother told my brother and I "you know there's other things to do" to which we replied "not until we finish this game!".
5. Zelda: OOT: Also not going to rehash the arguments for this one I just freaking loved this game.
6. Metal Gear Solid: Alongside FFVII, this is one of the most sentimental games to me. Those two games exposed a darker tone than anything I was familiar with and the sort of solitary sadness of the game just sucked me in. It was also the most cinematic experience ever. My mother had been overhearing the dialogue was even pulled into the story a bit which I found funny.
7. Half-Life: Not too much to say other than this game broke the walls to prove that an FPS can tell a story. Also the firefights in this game were freaking amazing.
8. Supreme Commander: This game is everything an RTS should be. Focus is on strategy and not micromanagement and I love it. Shame it wasn't supported better as there are still some lingering balance issues and bugs. My friends and I still play this against each other.
9. COD4: Modern Warfare: I've spent over 13 days of online time playing this thing fully maxing out my level after Prestiging 10 times so I felt I had to include this one.